My experience in Montreal for the ATP Rogers Cup this year was AWESOME. The venue, the atmosphere, the people and the tennis all exceeded my expectations. Up until this morning, I was really looking forward to the possibility of heading back there in 2011 in an attempt to duplicate my positive experience with the tournament. Well, it looks like that might not be happening.
Starting in 2011, the WTA and ATP Tours are making Tennis Canada hold both the men’s and women’s tournaments during the same week. Obviously Tennis Canada doesn’t want to lose the money it has made by staggering the two tournaments and they want to give people an opportunity to see both WTA and ATP players in a single year. So what do they plan on doing? Splitting both draws between Toronto and Montreal, of course.
The proposal would put one-half of each of the women’s and the men’s draws in Toronto and the other half in Montreal. They would play through their halves of the draw as normal then after completing the semifinals, one winner from either the ATP or WTA would fly to Toronto and the winner of the opposite would fly to Montreal. Yes, that’s really what they’re proposing. This is one of the WORST ideas they could have possibly come up with and here is just a couple reasons why:
Tickets – I’m not really into a lot of the WTA events right now. There just aren’t many successful players who are capturing my attention. Sure I’d like to see Safina, Clijsters, Sharapova or Cornet, but if they were playing at the same time as Federer, Nadal, Murray, Tsonga, Roddick, or just about anybody ranked through #70 (Robby Ginepri) – and even a few names ranked below him – I would skip their matches in a second.
I’d really like to see which side of the draw most my favorite players are on before I buy my tickets. Also, there’s a chance that there might be some better matches on one end and some potential blowouts on the other. I don’t want to run the risk of buying Montreal tickets a month in advance and ending up going to a draw with Murray, Djokovic, Del Potro and Davydenko when I could be seeing Federer, Nadal, Roddick and Tsonga. I like the former 4 players a lot, don’t get me wrong, but I’d like to be presented with an opportunity to see all 8 of them and not four of them, Safina, Venus and company.
The draw is released the weekend before the tournament begins, so I’d think that a lot of people would hold off on purchasing tickets until the draw has been released. If that happens, it’s very possible, even probable, that it would result in a flood of phone calls for one event and a lesser amount of sales for the other. You’re going to have the locals who go the closest event no matter what, so those are guaranteed sales, but it’s going to hurt for people who are traveling with the intent to see their favorite players. You can’t book hotels in advance, plan other events aside from the tournaments, etc. This will be a major disadvantage for the Rogers Cup against tournaments.
Doubles – They have been doing a GREAT job recently in encouraging some of the bigger names to come out of the doubles draw. Tsonga, Nadal, Djokovic, Davydenko, Simon, Haas, Robredo, Ferrer, and Wawrinka are just some of the names involved in the doubles draw at the Montreal even this year. That’s not even including the top ranked doubles teams.
Should they split up the event, they’re going to lose the momentum that the tours have been working to build for the doubles scene. You run the risk of separating regular partners, people not being able to commit to doubles until they know which site they’re going to be designated to and a loss in fan interest about doubles. One of the better attended matches that I went to while in Montreal was Nadal/Roig vs Djokovic/Vemic.

The court was filled before the prior match had even finished. People were rushing to find seating so they could watch this match. All of the seats were taken, people were sitting in the aisles and standing all along the available perimeter just to catch a glimpse of the two top 4 players and to see Nadal play in his first match since his loss to Robin Soderling at the French Open. There was a crowd gathered at Uniprix Stadium, watching over the rails and neglecting the match that was on the center court.

It’s possible that Nadal wouldn’t have even played this match had the event been split between two cities. What if his doubles matches were in Toronto and singles in Montreal? Obviously the doubles event is the casualty. So the match that was the highlight for many on that day wouldn’t have even happened.
I’m sure you can argue for it. There have to some positive elements out there. I’m sure there are some people who would love to take a chance on seeing two halves of both draws and hope for a line-up of stars. I’m not one of those people, though. You’ll find me heading to other tournaments instead and that’s too bad because I really enjoyed my first experience with the Rogers Cup.